At the beginning of the series Silo, before we even know what has happened to the world, we are given an official account—a narrative meant both to explain the past and to justify the present: “We don’t know why we’re here. We don’t know who built the silo. We don’t know why everything outside the silo is the way it is. We don’t know when it will be safe to go outside. We only know that today is not that day.”
These few sentences establish the grand narrative of Silo, presented with as little information as possible: after an unknown catastrophe, human beings took refuge in silos; the outside world is deadly, and nobody knows why; therefore, the only way to survive is to remain inside. Alongside this narrative is a fundamental principle: the past is lost, and asking questions about it is dangerous. The inhabitants do not even know who built the silo or why they live in it. But the crucial point is that “not knowing” in Silo is not simply a lack of information. Not knowing is itself the mechanism that keeps this world alive, an integral part of its social culture. The question is which things are allowed to become public knowledge.
This logic recurs across the series’ two storylines, one set in the present and the other in the “Before Times.” In the past, Daniel and Helen obtain information about the Silo project—information initially available only to a select few, which must then be kept out of public circulation to preserve the secret. In the present-day storyline, the inhabitants are equally ignorant of the past, the outside world, the other silos, and the system’s actual mechanisms. Season Three connects these two timelines, revealing that the control of memory has been part of the system’s logic from the very beginning. In the present, Juliet’s memory manipulation and Daniel’s recurring cycles of memory erasure represent a more fully developed and organized form of the same policy. Silo thus transforms from a world in which the truth is hidden into one in which the transmission of truth itself is controlled.
From Controlling Information to Controlling Communication
If information were merely concealed from people, resistance would still be possible. Someone could discover something, share it with another person, and gradually help build a body of collective knowledge. That is why the system in Silo does not control information alone; it also controls communication.
This control is visible within the silo itself. Access to information, technology, old documents, objects from the Before Times, and even certain words is restricted. Communication and information flow through designated channels, while institutions such as IT act as intermediaries between individuals and knowledge. Even relatively simple technologies that could expand people’s ability to record, retrieve, or transmit information are not fully available to the public.
At a larger scale, however, control over communication takes on another meaning: communication between silos. If each silo knew that other silos existed, its inhabitants would no longer regard their own world as the only possible world. They could make comparisons. They could ask what rules govern life in other silos, how people live there, what they know, what they do not know, and why. Most importantly, they could communicate with one another. At this point, information ceases to be merely an individual matter and becomes a political one. Knowing that an “other” exists creates the possibility of collective organization.
For this reason, the separation of the silos cannot be understood merely as a technical measure designed to prevent the spread of rebellion. It eliminates the possibility of a larger community emerging beyond the small society contained within each silo. A rebellion in one silo can be suppressed, but a rebellion capable of connecting itself to another is a different matter entirely. The system does not need to convince everyone that the official narrative is true. It only needs to prevent people from collectively producing and transmitting an alternative narrative. The final sentence of the silo’s grand narrative—“We only know that today is not that day”—rests precisely on this point. Not knowing when the outside will be safe makes comparison impossible.
Why Must Juliet Lose Her Memory?
Juliet’s return from the outside is one of the series’ most important moments because she has witnessed the truth about the world beyond the silo. She is now a witness. The system wants its own account to remain the only account available. But Juliet can offer an alternative narrative and call the silo’s official version into question. She is no longer someone who claims, on the basis of a document or a rumor, that the official story is a lie. She has seen the outside world and learned that another silo exists. Her body and memory therefore carry information that the system cannot allow to become public knowledge. If that happens, the inhabitants may begin asking: if this account is a lie, what else might be a lie?
In Season Three, the manipulation of Juliet’s memory after her return brings this issue directly to the foreground. The series even titles one of its episodes “Memory,” showing how recollection can resist such intervention. Here, there is an important difference between censorship and the erasure of memory. When confronted with censorship, a person knows that certain information is forbidden, and that very prohibition can provoke curiosity. But when memory itself is manipulated, the witness becomes an unreliable source of truth.
The Before Times storyline repeats the same logic on an even more horrifying scale. In Season Three, we see those involved in the project distancing themselves from the truth through confidentiality agreements—that is, agreements involving memory and even its erasure. By the end of the season, it becomes clear that Daniel has repeatedly awakened under another identity, unaware of his own past, with parts of his personal history beyond his reach. The system therefore does not merely want people to lack information. It wants to determine what they remember and what they forget. Memory, in this world, no longer belongs exclusively to the private sphere. It becomes an infrastructure of history, and controlling history requires access to individual memories.
Why Is the Level of Technology Deliberately Kept Low?
One of the interesting contradictions of Silo is that its world is not quite as primitive as it appears. Hidden within the system are highly advanced technologies, ranging from computational infrastructure and algorithms to technologies involving memory and long-term sleep. The problem, then, is not that humanity in the silos has lost advanced technology. It is that this technology is not accessible to everyone.
If people had access to advanced tools for recording, communicating, storing, and transmitting information, controlling knowledge would become more difficult. A camera, a communications network, a searchable archive, or even a simple device for recording experiences could transform individual memory into collective memory.
Primitive tools, meanwhile, make everything more difficult and extend the working day. Life revolves constantly around labor, maintenance, repair, production, and survival. Free time is not merely time for rest. It can also be time for thinking, curiosity, creativity, invention, and asking questions the system would prefer to leave unasked. Perhaps the system does not want people merely to stay alive. It wants them to remain alive within a defined framework, permanently confined to the condition of survival.
Keeping the technological level low is therefore another component of the same policy of information control. People are deprived both of the truth and of some of the tools that might enable them to produce an alternative account of reality. This is why technology and power cannot be separated in Silo. Any technology that expands the ability to see, record, remember, or communicate is potentially a political problem. From this perspective, the opening narrative—“We don’t know when it will be safe to go outside”—is no longer merely a precautionary statement. It is the direct consequence of having no independent means of determining whether the outside world is safe.
Why Can a System Built to Save Humanity Kill Everyone It Was Meant to Protect?
Here, one of the most fundamental contradictions in Silo emerges. On the surface, the silos were built to save humanity. In order to survive a catastrophe, human beings were moved into an enclosed refuge. Yet the very system designed to protect them also possesses the capacity to kill the entire population of a silo through a mechanism known as Safeguard. Season Two introduces this mechanism as a lethal protocol, while Season Three reveals more about the control exercised over Silo 1 and the algorithm governing it.
This contradiction becomes intelligible if we make a small adjustment to our definition of the system’s objective. If the goal is to save every individual human being, killing an entire silo’s population represents a system failure. But if the goal is to preserve the survival system itself, individuals can be sacrificed whenever they threaten it. Under this logic, human beings are no longer ends in themselves; they are units within a managed population. The system must survive, even if preserving itself requires eliminating some of the people it contains.
Safeguard, then, is not merely a weapon. It reveals what has truly occupied the center of this world from the beginning: humanity itself, or the machinery of survival.
If the System Erases the Past to Prevent Rebellion, Why Does Rebellion Return?
This may be the most important structural paradox in Silo. In the past, a rebellion occurred and was extinguished by adding what was supposedly a vitamin to the water, which erased people’s memories. Yet several years later, the same thing happened again. The process appears to continue in recurring cycles: part of society becomes suspicious; hidden information is discovered; someone asks questions; the official narrative is called into doubt; rebellion takes shape; the system intervenes; memories are erased; and society returns to its previous state.
But erasing the past does not eliminate the causes of discontent. It only removes the knowledge associated with them. As a result, the same conditions are reproduced, and the same questions eventually arise again. In other words, instead of learning from history, the system erases history—and that is precisely why it is condemned to repeat it.
This repetition is not an accidental flaw in the system. It is the logical consequence of the solution the system has chosen. A system incapable of correcting itself in response to new information has no choice but to eliminate that information. By the end of Season Three, this logic takes on an intensely personal dimension in Daniel’s case: an individual is separated not only from collective history but also from his own personal history, placed back into the same cycle. The cycle that began with the series’ opening grand narrative is now reproduced within Daniel’s individual memory.
An Architecture Built in the Image of the System’s Logic
Perhaps the most interesting point, however, is that this logic is not conveyed through the story alone. It is also visible in the silo’s architecture. The silo is not a horizontal space. It is a vast vertical structure, with floor stacked upon floor and staircase upon staircase. People are constantly moving up and down, yet almost always along the same vertical axis. Even the spiral staircase can be read as an echo of the repetitive cycle of life inside the silo.
This architecture also makes the silo’s social divisions visible. Different sections occupy different heights, and access to them is unequal. The various levels hold different positions within the structures of power and labor. The higher people climb, the further they penetrate into the system’s structure. This may be one of the silo’s central contradictions: moving upward does not necessarily mean moving toward freedom.
In such a space, horizontal movement, which could bring people together, is less important than vertical movement. Even the silo’s physical form is consistent with the logic of separation: discrete units, limited communication, and movement along a prescribed axis.
Outside, too, we encounter a world that seemingly has no horizon. The inhabitants see the outside through a screen, as a limited and controlled image. For them, the outside is an inaccessible space, reduced to a picture. Even the concrete surfaces and the scarcity of openings and windows point toward the same idea. Inside and outside are divided into two separate domains: the outside is unsafe but free; the inside is safe but unfree. Those within the silo receive the system’s protection, while anyone who no longer enjoys that protection is exiled outside.
The opposition between inside and outside is therefore not simply a contrast between two locations. The interior of the silo has become a system of floors, rules, and controlled routes, while the exterior has become an image that people are not permitted to experience directly. This is how the building’s form becomes inseparable from the story’s central concerns.
From Building to Story
We can now bring these separate threads together. Information, communication, memory, technology, Safeguard, and architecture all reproduce the same underlying logic at different levels: the logic expressed in the series’ opening sentences.
We can even think of the entire silo as a vast machine for managing distance: the distance between people and the past, between individuals and information, between one person and another, between one silo and another, and between humanity and the outside world. Memory reduces this distance, so it must be controlled. Communication reduces it, so it must be restricted. Technology can eliminate it, so access to technology must be controlled. Rebellion can connect people, so it must be suppressed. And if all these barriers fail, Safeguard stands ready to eliminate the population itself.
From this perspective, Silo is not simply a story about people living in an enclosed, capsule-like environment. It is about a system that, in order to preserve itself, has gradually restricted every means through which society might connect with its past, with other people, and with the possibility of a different life.
This is where the title Silo acquires another meaning. In its literal sense, a silo is a tall, enclosed structure designed to store something separately from its surroundings. The world of the series has precisely this structure: human beings are kept in units separated from one another, information is stored in isolated compartments, and memory is manipulated within individuals to keep the world sealed.
But this is also where the ultimate paradox lies. A system built to prevent humanity’s destruction has been forced, in order to preserve itself, to separate human beings from history, from communication, and from the possibility of imagining a future. In such a world, the central question is no longer what exists outside. The question is this: if, in order to survive, you must forget your past, lose your connections with other people, and surrender even the ability to imagine another kind of life, what exactly have you saved of “life” itself?
© 2026. Phoenix Review


