EssaysFilm

Love or Psychological Self-Torture in Of Human Bondage | A Look at John Cromwell’s Adaptation of Somerset Maugham’s Novel

Of Human Bondage

John Cromwell’s Of Human Bondage (1934), the first Hollywood film adaptation of Somerset Maugham’s masterpiece Of Human Bondage, offers a condensed account of the novel. Yet the film’s real strength lies not in its complete fidelity to Maugham’s work, but in its ability to find visual equivalents for a difficult psychological experience: that of a man who is held captive less by the woman he loves than by his own mental image of love. Working with screenwriter Lester Cohen, Cromwell succeeds in transforming a lengthy, introspective, philosophical novel into a compact melodrama about desire, humiliation, dependency, and liberation.

Of Human Bondage tells the story of Philip Carey (Leslie Howard), a young medical student who becomes trapped in a cycle of hope, humiliation, and emotional dependency after falling into a destructive, unrequited love for Mildred Rogers (played by Bette Davis, who became a star with this film), an arrogant, self-absorbed waitress. Somerset Maugham’s novel depicts the hardships and suffering associated with one-sided love. Philip Carey is a sensitive orphan whose congenital disability in one foot leaves him acutely aware of the absence of love and support in his life. Abandoning his studies, he travels first to Heidelberg and then to Paris, where his earliest dreams of becoming a great artist begin to take shape. But after confronting the realities of life and realizing how little influence he has over the world, Philip loses the idealism of his youth. Upon returning to London to study medicine, he becomes infatuated with a waitress named Mildred and enters a pathological romantic relationship that permanently alters the course of his life. In an attempt to forget Mildred, Philip becomes involved with Norah Nesbit, a writer of romantic fiction, but he remains unable to free himself from his obsessive attraction to Mildred. He returns to her after her husband abandons her. Following the birth of her child, however, Mildred betrays Philip and begins an affair with another medical student, who eventually abandons her as well. Philip then meets a beautiful young woman named Sally Athelny. Wounded by Philip’s sudden coldness toward her, Mildred calls him a “ridiculous little cripple” and destroys all his paintings.

Within a relatively short running time, Cromwell traces Philip Carey’s psychological journey from self-loathing and artistic idealism to the acceptance of an ordinary life, although this compression comes at the cost of many of the novel’s social and philosophical subtleties. One of the film’s most important thematic elements is the relationship between the body and identity. Philip’s deformed, clubbed foot is not merely a physical characteristic; his disability becomes an outward manifestation of his deeply ingrained sense of inadequacy. Philip believes that his deformity sets him apart from others and deprives him of the possibility of love, success, and an ordinary life. Cromwell’s camera conveys this perception by emphasizing Philip’s impaired foot and the way he walks. This emphasis, however, is strikingly cruel. Before Philip is even introduced as a character, the film presents him to us through his physical disability. In effect, society’s humiliating gaze upon his body has seeped into the camera’s own gaze. The motif’s real significance, however, lies in its subsequent development. When surgery enables Philip to walk normally, his fundamental problems remain unresolved. He is still trapped economically, emotionally, and psychologically. The film thus suggests that Philip’s real disability lies not in his foot but in the image he has constructed of himself and in the dependency he has developed on Mildred. Even after his physical deformity is corrected, he remains captive to his own illusions and desires.

The film employs an intriguing visual contrast to explore this dynamic. Philip’s irregular, labored movements are set against Mildred’s quick, seemingly carefree gestures. Philip carries a kind of psychological heaviness in the way he moves, whereas Mildred uses her body and stride to project control and indifference. Mildred is not simply a cruel woman, a femme fatale, or an evil lover. She is the focal point of a conflict between desire and humiliation. Philip sees Mildred not as she is, but as he wants her to be. He fails to distinguish between the reality of Mildred—a vulgar, self-centered woman who is emotionally callous—and the idealized image he has constructed of her in his mind. The film renders this gap visible through its mise-en-scène and compositions. In certain scenes, Mildred appears against Philip’s paintings and sketches, as though her actual body were merging with the imaginary, aestheticized image he has created of her. In reality, Philip is not in love with Mildred herself, but with the image of Mildred he has fashioned for himself. The use of these paintings underscores the connection between Philip’s failure in art and his failure in love.

In the scene of their first meeting at the restaurant, the characters’ apparent social positions are also inverted. As an educated man, Philip occupies a higher social position than Mildred, who works as a waitress. Yet from the outset, Mildred dominates him psychologically. Cromwell’s mise-en-scène, his choice of camera angles, and the positioning of the characters’ bodies within the frame expose these hidden power relations. Socially, Mildred is a woman of lower status, but within the realm of desire, she becomes an almost unattainable, worshipped object.

At many of the film’s crucial moments, Cromwell relies on direct, frontal close-ups of the actors. Philip’s and Mildred’s faces confront one another in close-up, sometimes through alternating reverse shots. These images allow the viewer to observe the smallest emotional shifts while transforming the film’s space into a battleground of gazes. Mildred’s close-ups, particularly in Bette Davis’s performance, construct a dual image of her: a face that is both attractive and lifeless, both vulnerable and aggressive. Through brief pauses, fixed stares, sudden shifts in vocal tone, and precise control of her facial muscles, Davis suggests that Mildred suffers from emotional emptiness more than she is in love or even embodies the classical femme fatale. By contrast, Leslie Howard’s close-ups emphasize Philip’s hesitation, shame, and expectation. His face often reveals the character’s psychological defeat before the dialogue has a chance to explain it. In this way, the film conveys part of the novel’s inner language through the actor’s face.

This approach, however, is not always consistent. The film relies too heavily on frontal close-ups and alternating reverse shots, reducing some of the novel’s spatial and psychological complexity to direct dialogue and facial performance.

Despite the limitations of studio production in 1934, the film makes meaningful use of camera movement in several scenes. Camera movement here serves not merely as a source of visual variety but often as an expression of the characters’ psychological states. Tracking shots following Philip through streets, restaurants, and interior spaces embody his restlessness and his attraction to Mildred. By contrast, tight framing and more static compositions intensify the sense of entrapment, confinement, and repetition. One of the key features of this visual design is the oscillation between movement and stillness. Philip is constantly changing direction: from art to medicine, from London to Paris, from Mildred to Sally, and from one possible life to another. Psychologically, however, he remains fixed in place. His external movements cannot free him from his inner bondage. The use of lighting, superimposition, and subjective imagery further conveys the distance between reality and fantasy. In one scene, as Philip studies anatomy, the filmmaker uses a dissolve to transform the body he is studying into an image of Mildred. This transition suggests that, for Philip, Mildred has become both an object of knowledge and an object of desire. In this way, the film intertwines medicine, art, and desire within Philip’s mind.

The film’s settings, particularly its streets and interior sets, sometimes appear conspicuously artificial and confined by the studio environment. Yet this limitation is not always a weakness. The relatively simple, repetitive sets can reflect the routine and mechanical character of Philip’s life. The medical spaces, rooms, and corridors do less to establish a broad social world than to function as enclosures in which the characters are trapped. This artificial quality also corresponds to Philip’s mental state. He experiences the world not as an open and diverse reality, but as a series of enclosed spaces and predetermined roles: the patient, the failed artist, the medical student, and the frustrated lover. In this sense, the film’s production constraints sometimes become part of its expressive language. The simple, unostentatious sets, largely devoid of decorative detail, reinforce the suffocating monotony of Philip’s existence.

John Cromwell’s Of Human Bondage is not—and could not be—a completely faithful adaptation of every dimension of Maugham’s novel. The novel is far more expansive than the film. It is not simply the story of Philip and Mildred’s love affair, but also an account of the formation of Philip’s character, his artistic experiences in Paris, his medical studies, class relations, poverty, work, religion, friendship, death, and his search for the meaning of life. Cromwell was necessarily obliged to eliminate a substantial portion of the novel. The opening is considerably condensed, while several secondary storylines, including many of Philip’s artistic experiences and relationships, are omitted. The film moves rapidly from his failure as an artist to his entry into medicine, before concentrating primarily on his relationship with Mildred. Cromwell’s adaptation is therefore better understood as a psychological melodrama about obsessive love than as a cinematic portrait of a man’s intellectual and philosophical development.

Nevertheless, the film remains faithful to the novel’s central narrative. Philip feels inferior because of his physical disability. He falls in love with Mildred, who has no genuine affection for him. He repeatedly breaks away from her, only to return. His desire for Mildred becomes a form of emotional self-torture, although by the end he appears to find peace through his marriage to a woman named Sally. In the novel, this ending is more closely associated with accepting an ordinary life and abandoning the search for absolute meaning. The film translates this idea into a more cinematic and accessible language. Philip escapes the bondage of pathological love and ultimately turns toward a reciprocal, attainable relationship.

The film’s ending thus initially appears, like that of many Hollywood melodramas, to be a happy and reassuring conclusion. Yet the film cannot entirely dispel Mildred’s shadow. Philip’s relationship with her is so deeply entangled with self-torture, fantasy, and desire that his new bond with Sally cannot necessarily heal all his wounds. This is what gives the ending much of its value. Had the film simply concluded with Philip and Sally’s marriage, it would have lapsed into conventional melodrama. Instead, the sorrow and exhaustion of Philip’s relationship with Mildred, together with the intensity of his dependency on her, suggest that his liberation is neither complete nor without cost. Sally represents the possibility of a life for Philip, but we cannot say with certainty that Mildred’s memory has been permanently erased from his psyche. The film’s final sense of peace therefore remains fragile and conditional, despite its reassuring appearance.

Besides Cromwell’s adaptation, two other film versions of Somerset Maugham’s Of Human Bondage have been made: the 1946 American version directed by Edmund Goulding and the 1964 British version directed by Ken Hughes, starring Laurence Harvey and Kim Novak. Compared with Cromwell’s film, Goulding’s version is more polished and studio-bound. Owing to Hollywood’s moral restrictions, it further tones down the novel’s sexual and social dimensions, diminishing the psychological intensity and bitterness of Philip and Mildred’s relationship. Despite omitting parts of the novel, Cromwell’s film remains the most complex and compelling cinematic interpretation of their relationship, thanks to Bette Davis’s unrestrained, abrasive performance and its effective use of close-ups, the body, and the gaze. The film succeeds remarkably well in translating Philip’s inner crisis into visual language. Its emphasis on Philip’s deformed foot, the contrast between movement and stillness, the close-ups of the characters’ faces, the juxtaposition of paintings and bodies, and its use of camera movement to express psychological states all demonstrate that Cromwell has done more than simply visualize Maugham’s story: he has interpreted it.

Ken Hughes’s version is more visually ambitious. With cinematography by Oswald Morris and production design by John Box, it reconstructs Edwardian London in greater detail, bringing to life gas-lit streets and impoverished neighborhoods. Yet compared with Cromwell’s version, it has less emotional impact. We can therefore argue that Cromwell’s film focuses more intensely than the two later adaptations on the psychological experience of Philip and Mildred’s destructive power, whereas Hughes’s version leans more heavily toward the historical and visual reconstruction of the novel’s world.

The most significant changes Cromwell made in adapting Maugham’s novel stem from Hollywood’s moral restrictions and censorship during the period before the full implementation of the Hays Code in American cinema. In the novel, Mildred’s fate is bound up with prostitution, syphilis, and social degradation. The film removes or softens these elements, changing her illness to tuberculosis. Prostitution, too, is never addressed directly. These alterations transform the meaning of Mildred’s downfall. In the novel, her decline is partly a consequence of social structures, gender, poverty, and personal choices. The film, however, presents her primarily as a cruel, selfish woman who ultimately becomes a victim of illness. As a result, the social complexity of her character is diminished, while her role within the melodrama becomes more pronounced.

The film also simplifies and romanticizes Philip’s relationship with Sally. In the novel, Philip’s decision to marry Sally develops through the question of whether she might be pregnant, followed by the discovery that the pregnancy scare was mistaken. The film eliminates this storyline and builds its ending around Philip’s liberation from Mildred and his direct choice of Sally. The film’s conclusion therefore places greater emphasis on “emotional salvation” than the novel’s ending does.

The film’s most important achievement lies in transforming “bondage” from a purely romantic concept into a relationship among the body, the social gaze, desire, and self-abasement.

© 2026. Phoenix Review

Shares:
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *